York is one of the older American HVAC brands — founded in 1874 in York, Pennsylvania, and now owned by Johnson Controls. It occupies a mid-to-premium market position. Goodman is the value leader, owned by Daikin. If you're comparing these two for a Minnesota furnace replacement, here's what actually matters.
Brand Overview
Goodman: Manufactured in Houston, TX by Daikin Industries (world's largest HVAC company). Focuses on reliable equipment at competitive pricing. Sold through wholesale distributors. Excellent parts availability across North America. York: Manufactured by Johnson Controls, which also makes Coleman and Luxaire brands under the same parent. Sold through a dealer network similar to Trane and Carrier. York emphasizes technology and premium features in their residential lineup.
Buy the same name-brand furnace the pros install — shipped factory-direct to your door. No middleman, free delivery, 5-star rated, and financing available.
Efficiency Comparison
| Tier | Goodman | York |
|---|---|---|
| Entry | GMSS96 — 96% AFUE, single-stage | TM9E — 96% AFUE, single-stage |
| Mid | GMVC96 — 96% AFUE, two-stage, ECM | TG9E — 96% AFUE, two-stage, ECM |
| Premium | GMVM97 — 97% AFUE, modulating | YP9C — 98% AFUE, modulating, ECM |
Both brands offer comparable efficiency at entry and mid tiers. York's premium YP9C reaches 98% AFUE vs. Goodman's 97% GMVM97 — a 1% difference that translates to roughly $12–$15/year in gas savings for a typical Minnesota home. Not a meaningful purchasing factor.
Pricing
York equipment, sold through dealers, carries pricing in the Lennox/Carrier range — mid-to-premium. Equipment cost through dealers typically runs 30–60% more than comparable Goodman purchased at factory-direct wholesale pricing from Furnace Direct. The difference is real and can reach $800–$1,500 on a mid-range furnace.
Reliability
Both brands perform adequately when properly installed. York has had some reported control board reliability issues on certain model lines in recent years, though no systemic widespread problems. Goodman's reliability has improved significantly since the Daikin acquisition. Installation quality remains the dominant factor for both brands.
Warranty
Both offer 10-year registered parts / lifetime heat exchanger — effectively identical warranty structures. No meaningful difference here.
The Verdict
For most Minnesota homeowners, Goodman delivers equivalent performance at significantly lower equipment cost. The 1% efficiency edge at York's premium tier doesn't justify the price premium. York makes sense primarily if you have an established dealer relationship or prefer their specific dealer service network.
Browse Goodman at factory-direct pricing: furnace.direct/collections/heating
Related reading: Gas Furnace Brands Ranked | Goodman vs. Trane | Goodman vs. Lennox
Get wholesale pricing on a new system.
Tell us a little about your home and what you're replacing. We'll send real numbers on a Goodman 96% AFUE setup — shipped direct to your door anywhere in the lower 48. No contractor markup, no obligation.