Getting multiple HVAC quotes sounds straightforward—but most homeowners don't know what to look for, and end up comparing apples to oranges. One quote might include an 80% furnace, another a 96%. One might include removing the old furnace, another might not. One contractor might be padding equipment margins by 40%, another selling cost-effectively.
This guide teaches Minnesota homeowners exactly how to solicit, read, and compare HVAC quotes so you make an informed decision—not just pick the cheapest number.
Why Multiple Quotes Matter
HVAC installation is one of the largest home expenses a homeowner faces—typically $3,000–$8,000 for a furnace replacement, $8,000–$15,000+ for a full system. Yet studies show most homeowners get only one quote, which means paying whatever that contractor charges.
In the HVAC industry, equipment markups vary wildly. Some contractors mark up furnaces 50–100% over wholesale cost. Others mark up 20%. Getting three quotes can save you $500–$3,000 on the same job, depending on the contractor and equipment brand.
Before You Call Anyone: Know What You Have
Document your existing system before getting quotes:
- Furnace brand and model (label on side of furnace)
- Age of furnace (manufacture date on label or serial number decoder)
- Square footage of home
- Number of stories
- Insulation quality (well-insulated, average, drafty older home)
- Venting type (PVC pipes for high-efficiency, metal chimney for 80%)
- Gas line size (if known)
- Any ductwork issues you're aware of
Also decide in advance whether you want to replace just the furnace, the furnace + AC coil, or the full system including outdoor unit. Having clarity here prevents contractors from steering you toward whatever they want to sell.
How to Solicit Quotes the Right Way
Get Exactly Three Quotes
One quote = no comparison. Two quotes = easy to pick the lower one without understanding why. Three quotes = you have a real market baseline and can identify outliers in both directions.
Be Specific in Your Request
Tell each contractor the same thing: "I need a quote to replace my furnace with a 96% AFUE, two-stage unit with a variable-speed motor, installed including removal of the old unit, new PVC venting if needed, condensate drain, and permit." Specific requests force comparable bids.
Ask What Brand/Model They Quote
Make sure you know exactly what equipment each contractor is proposing. "A furnace" means nothing. "Goodman GMVC96, 80,000 BTU" means something you can look up and compare.
Verify Licensing
In Minnesota, HVAC contractors must hold a valid mechanical contractor license. Verify at the Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry website before accepting any quote. Unlicensed contractors void manufacturer warranties and may fail inspection.
What Every Quote Should Include
A legitimate HVAC quote should spell out:
- Exact equipment brand, model number, and BTU size
- AFUE efficiency rating
- Labor cost (separated from equipment)
- Removal and disposal of old equipment
- Permit cost (if required)
- Any new venting materials and installation
- Condensate drain work
- Thermostat (new or reuse existing)
- Warranty on installation labor (typically 1–2 years)
- Equipment warranty details
- Timeline for completion
If any of these items are missing, ask for clarification before signing. A vague quote often leads to change order surprises after work begins.
The Equipment Markup Problem
Here's what most homeowners don't know: HVAC contractors buy equipment at wholesale cost and mark it up before selling it to you. A furnace that costs a contractor $800 might appear on your quote as $1,800. That's a 125% markup, and it's common.
The alternative: purchase your equipment separately at factory-direct pricing through a supplier like Furnace Direct, then hire a contractor to install it. You pay wholesale for the equipment, contractor rates for labor. This approach typically saves $500–$2,000 on the equipment portion alone.
When comparing quotes, always ask contractors to break out equipment cost and labor cost separately. If they refuse, ask why. Transparent contractors have no problem with this.
Quote Comparison Template
| Line Item | Contractor A | Contractor B | Contractor C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equipment brand/model | |||
| BTU size | |||
| AFUE efficiency | |||
| Equipment cost | |||
| Labor cost | |||
| Permit included? | |||
| Old unit removal included? | |||
| New venting included? | |||
| Thermostat included? | |||
| Installation warranty | |||
| Total price | |||
| Timeline |
Red Flags in HVAC Quotes
- Vague equipment description: "New high-efficiency furnace" without model numbers
- Pressure to decide immediately: "This price is only good today"
- Refuses to itemize equipment vs. labor: Often hiding large markup
- No permit mentioned: Some contractors skip permits to save time, leaving you liable
- Significantly lowest price: Could mean unlicensed, no permit, inferior equipment, or cut corners
- No written quote: Verbal quotes have no legal standing
- Oversized equipment recommendation without load calculation: Bigger isn't better
Questions to Ask Every Contractor
- Are you licensed in Minnesota for HVAC mechanical work?
- Will you pull a permit for this installation?
- What exact model number are you quoting?
- Can you break out equipment cost and labor cost separately?
- How did you size this furnace? Did you do a Manual J calculation?
- What warranty do you provide on your installation labor?
- How long have you been in business and do you have references?
- Who does the actual installation — your employees or subcontractors?
The Factory-Direct Strategy
One powerful strategy: buy your furnace at factory-direct wholesale pricing through Furnace Direct, then get labor-only quotes from contractors. This separates equipment cost (where markup is highest) from labor cost (where competition is strongest).
Steps:
- Determine the correct model and size for your home (we can help)
- Purchase at wholesale through Furnace Direct — same-day delivery in Minneapolis-St. Paul metro
- Get 2–3 labor-only installation quotes from licensed contractors
- Select the best labor quote
This approach puts equipment cost control in your hands, not the contractor's. Many contractors are happy to install customer-supplied equipment—just confirm upfront.
Related Resources
- Furnace Replacement vs. Repair: How to Decide
- How to Size a Furnace for Your Minnesota Home
- Minnesota Furnace Permit Requirements
- HVAC Financing Options for Minnesota Homeowners
- What Your Installer Should Do: Goodman Furnace Guide
Do you know your model number?
Search your exact replacement — or let us match you to the right unit in 60 seconds.
Search by Model
Enter your furnace or AC model number to find your exact factory-direct replacement.
Take the 60-Second Quiz
Answer 4 quick questions and we'll match you to the right furnace for your home and budget.
🏠 Take the 60-Second QuizGet installed pricing on a new system.
Tell us a little about your home and what you're replacing. We'll send real numbers on a Goodman 96% AFUE setup — equipment shipped nationwide, licensed install in select metros. No contractor markup, no obligation.